Why individual OKRs don’t work

Find your focus, establish context, set priorities as a team

Most major “what people want from work” studies of the past decade have shown that (a) compensation and (b) opportunities for future growth—often linked topics—are typically the two biggest factors people look for in employers.

After all, employees have lives, and families, and aging parents, and mortgages, and broader needs. Therefore, companies need to be advancing the individual at some level. Doing so is clearly tied to retention, and turnover is a bottom-line hit.

Unfortunately, on the path to individual development, companies tend to make two fundamental mistakes:

That second mistake is increasingly demonstrated in how companies roll out OKRs, or Objectives and Key Results. When done properly, OKRs are a great way to give everyone a broader view of where the business is headed. When done wrong? Well, it’s not often pretty.

The problems with setting individual OKRs

1. Employees ultimately put individual objectives above company objectives

OKRs were never intended to be about individual performance, although many an HR manager still believes that’s a potential function of the concept. Instead, OKRs are about focusing employees, teams, and the whole organization on the greatest collective business impact.

One core problem of individual OKRs is often that employees will put their individual goals above the goals of the company; this can have disastrous effects on any semblance of “culture” or “employer brand.” Your business becomes a group of people hustling for themselves. While some might like that idea on its face, it tends to tank any sense of priority or ability for employees to work cross-functionally. Top performers may get some major things achieved with a focus on individual OKRs, but the overall organization suffers.

2. Individual OKRs introduce unnecessary complexity

Another challenge to consider: managers are often overwhelmed as it is with meetings, check-ins, admin work, etc. If they are already managing team OKRs and need to add individual OKRs, that’s an additional level of complexity to track and report on. All of these tracking elements reduce the amount of time managers have to have conversations and contextualize the work and broader objectives for the team.

3. Individual OKRs reduce employee autonomy

Individual OKRs prescribe how employees should go about doing their work and achieving their end goal instead of just providing a north star to guide themselves there. For example, if a marketing team’s objective is to grow brand awareness and the related key results have been identified, what additional granularity does a marketing manager need to go about performing his/her job?

Diving even a level deeper turns into dictating specifically how that person does their job—what activities they should do to increase brand awareness—and does not allow them the autonomy to figure out what is and isn’t working for the company. Know what tends to happen when you reduce autonomy among your employees? You greatly increase turnover.

OKRs were never supposed to be tasks. Unfortunately, they can feel that way in individual OKR contexts. Consider this breakdown from how Spotify looks at it:

Successful companies tend to lead with the “why”. The “why” should lead naturally to the “what,” which then becomes the “how.” Individual OKRs for everyone can muddle this flow and become lengthy to-do lists, and work in many organizations has become too much about tasks as it is.

So, how should you implement OKRs?

Use OKRs at a team level.

At the individual level, it is okay to have one person own one or more metrics, making them primarily responsible for a set of key results. Managers can also work with individual employees to explain the “why” of the organization and tie a high-level individual goal to that “why.” Keep in mind, however, that this requires a deeper view of what’s happening beyond simply an individual employee task list.

Join the Range Newsletter

Get practical advice on building great teams

Don't worry. We don't like spam either. We'll only use your email address to send you the Range Newsletter and occasional updates about Range. We will never sell your information to third parties and you can unsubscribe at any time by contacting support@range.co. We use a third party provider, Mailchimp, to send our newsletter. We gather statistics around email openings and clicks using industry standard technologies. Find out more about our privacy practices.

Leadership is knowing when to let go

Micromanaging and tightly controlling your team will disempower them and erode initiative taking.

The essential guide to the 22 most common leadership styles

Get to know the 22 types of leadership from the 3 most common personality profiling tools. Which of the leadership types is yours?

8 lessons learned from our mini-conference on goal setting and OKRs

Whether new to or experienced with OKRs, here are 8 tips to help you take your objectives to the next level

We use cookies to offer you a better browsing experience, analyze site traffic, personalize content, and serve targeted advertisements. Read about how we use cookies in our privacy policy. If you continue to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies.